March 26, 2010, 2:06 pm
Where
women don't rule, globally: A scarcity of board seats
by Patricia Sellers
Where in the world are the fewest women
on major corporate boards?
Japan,
according to a study, out today, by Corporate Women
Directors International. The Washington-based group, known
as CWDI, counted women directors at the 200 largest
companies on
Fortune's
Global 500
list.
As of year-end, Japan has the
most companies with no women directors: 19. The all-male
boards include Toyota (TM), Honda (HMC), Nissan (NSANF),
Panasonic (PC), and Toshiba (TOSBF).
What gives? Besides cultural
stereotypes--age-old assumptions about the role of women in
society--there's the fact that in
Japan, most board seats go
to senior management. Since few women are senior managers in
Japan, they have little
access to the boardroom.
Though this may be changing, say the
researchers at CWDI.
Japan
has moved to adopt certain Western corporate governance
practices, including smaller boards and independent
directors. Sony (SNE) was a pioneer in recruiting outside
directors. So it's not surprising that Sony is a Japanese
outlier, with two women on its board.
Lack of diversity likely handicaps
Japanese companies, as studies suggest that the most
effective boards are balanced, gender-wise.
Boards in the U.S. have made
progress. One fifth of director seats at the largest U.S. companies, according to CWDI,
are occupied by women. Though in terms of percentage of
large-company director seats held by women,
Norway
scores best. That's because the government has mandated 40%
female representation at publicly listed companies.
Measuring board diversity this
way--by percentage of seats held by women--Japan is not worst in the world,
actually. What country is?
South Korea. It has five
companies in the top 200 of
Fortune's
Global 500. And the tally of women on those corporate
boards: Zero.